FEEDBACK PAGE

Thank you all kindly in advance for visiting my site!

Any and all comments, critiques, or observations, whether general or specific, would be much appreciated!

Please write to: feedback@attila-ataner.com

In your message, please specify the following:

     (1) Your name and return e-mail address;
     (2) whether your comment is general or specific to one or more photo(s);
     (3) if specific, please indicate which photos you are referring to by listing gallery title and photograph number (e.g., Airports No. 27/32);
     (4) if you wish to remain anonymous in providing feedback, please let me know.

All feedback, whether neutral, negative or positive, will be posted below.

Cheers!



FEEDBACK POSTINGS

IMAGE: Architecture (Night-time) No. 13/26
FROM: photoworkshop.com members
DATE: Various
 
COMMENT: Love the POV  [Point of View]/comp in this.  My eye goes straight to the moon.  Great job on the techs.  And good eye to see this. 
 
COMMENT: Wow! Great composition, colors and mood.  - Katia
 
COMMENT: Attila, I find these photograph an absolutely topper on these site here, concern the mood. The contrast between the black-tover and the “neon-tower”, with the little and small “nature strip”, its great. Fantastic work and more than a architecture photograph. - Friendly from John.
 
COMMENT: I remember seeing this in your portfolio, and for some reason it is more impressive there than it is here.  Is this the same image and the same crop as the one in the portfolio?  If so, then maybe it's the black border on either side in the portfolio presentation that helps it.
 
COMMENT: I like this image.  The composition works well--the juxtaposition of the mostly illuminated building with the mostly darkened one and the moon casting it's cloud diffused beams into the cool blue sky . . . terrific technicals.  Nice work!  - Peace, Dan.
 
COMMENT: Good detail, lighting, and point of view.  My eye is drawn directly to the moon.  The dark and light buildings complement each other well.
 
COMMENT: This really just jumped right out at me when I opened it!  Great use of comp, light and color!  Use of wide angle was a good choice, perfect for this. Wonderful depth! Well done.
 

 

IMAGE: Architecture (Night-time) No. 13/26
FROM: Juan Carlos Bretschneider [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 08, 2008; 02:38 P.M.
COMMENT: I've been staring at it for a while, I couldn't come out with much to say.....I guess sometimes you have to be content with just looking at something you like, and say nothing at all. Beauty may render you wordless.
 
IMAGE: Architecture (Night-time) No. 13/26
FROM: Marina Shcherbina [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 09, 2008; 05:56 P.M.
COMMENT: fantastic colours

 

IMAGE: Graffiti No. 4/7
FROM: photoworkshop.com members
DATE: Various
 
COMMENT: Love the comp & color. Great portfolio also.
 
COMMENT: I like this photo a lot.  Very strong composition.  Nice portfolio too!
 
COMMENT: An interesting scene.  Good lighting, good colors, and I like the POV.  I would like to see this scene without the trash barrel.
 
COMMENT: Excellent use of lighting and unusual perspective to create a visually impactful image. Very nice work.

 

IMAGE: Graffiti No. 4/7
FROM: Jörg Vetter [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 11, 2008; 07:05 P.M.
COMMENT: Great city shot. Message is clear. Well composed. BR Joerg
 
IMAGE: Graffiti No. 4/7
FROM: Pierre Dumas [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 11, 2008; 08:19 P.M.
COMMENT: Only the wire in the upper part don't play any role! Otherwise it's perfectly done all the way! - PDE
 
IMAGE: Graffiti No. 4/7
FROM: Sergio de los Reyes [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 11, 2008; 10:15 P.M.
COMMENT: Good one - I like so much, but I have a question: is this in Toronto? I have a very similar picture in a very similar place, but in Toronto, right on Bathurst st and Queen st. However, when I took my picture, the garbage bin was not there....Am I right?

 

IMAGE: Architecture (Daytime) 2 of 2 No. 1/30
FROM: Juan Carlos Bretschneider [photo.net member]
DATE:  June 11, 2008; 11:03 A.M.
COMMENT: As usual, a great image with a very unique approach a great composition and magnificent colors. Congratulations!

 

IMAGE: Iceland: Brief Impressions No. 28
FROM: Henrik Nilsson [photo.net member]
DATE: May 19, 2008; 08:23 P.M.
COMMENT: Hi Attila: I appreciate the comment you added when you posted the shot. So here are my two cents worth: I like what you tried to do. However, I find there my eyes wander all over it looking for some place to rest. The waterflow on the left side leads the viewer out of the image. The main waterflow doesn't have enough detail to hold my interest. The processing is also a bit overdone for me. Having said that, the idea of what you tried to do is good. Just keep working at it. All the best.
 
IMAGE: Iceland: Brief Impressions No. 28
FROM: L.J. Leonard [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 19, 2008; 09:34 P.M.
COMMENT: Not much to work with ... about all you could do is try a different type of cropping or unusual perspective. It's too dark to do much else with. hope this helps.
 
IMAGE: Iceland: Brief Impressions No. 28
FROM: Jörg Vetter [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 22, 2008; 06:06 P.M.
COMMENT: Its a difficult to make project. The light from the side might be better to have more shadows. However we cant often wait so long. BR Joerg

 

IMAGE: Family Portraits No. 9/10
FROM:  Henrik Nilsson [photo.net member]
DATE: May 19, 2008; 08:24 P.M.
COMMENT: Like this one quite a lot. Well done.

 

IMAGE: Aesthetic Formalism No. 14/19
FROM: Giuseppe Pasquali [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 12, 2008; 02:39 P.M.
COMMENT: It's a very interesting photo, well resolved as far as geometry and composition are concerned. The only minor bug (IMHO) is the contrast that seems a bit too much. Compliments, thank you, G.
 
IMAGE: Aesthetic Formalism No. 14/19
FROM: Jörg Vetter [photo.net member]
DATE: May 17, 2008; 05:32 P.M.
COMMENT: Creative work. - BR Joerg

 

IMAGE: Grayscale Variations No.  20/46
FROM: Gustavo Orensztajn [photo.net member]
DATE:  May 16, 2008; 03:20 A.M.
COMMENT: Very interesting abstract, nicely converted to BW

 

IMAGE: Pools No. 12/19
FROM: Janis Grodums [photo.net member]
DATE: May 10, 2008; 09:08 A.M.
COMMENT: 6/6 anonymously - I like this mood! Best regards! P.S. Maybe little crop ? ;)

 

IMAGE: Shadows No. 1/17
FROM: Giuseppe Pasquali [photo.net member]
DATE: May 07, 2008; 04:59 A.M.
COMMENT: A very difficult subject, well resolved. Compliments, thank you, G.

 

IMAGE: Aesthetic Formalism No. 11/19
FROM: Juan Carlos Bretschneider [photo.net member]
DATE: February 14, 2008; 09:24 A.M.
COMMENT: An unusual image, with great composition. In my opinion it takes someone with a very developed sense of aesthetics to even think about taking a picture such as this. Congratulations on your boldness and of course for a great result. Cheers!

 

IMAGE: Objects No. 7/18
FROM: Mathieu Di Muro [photo.net member]
DATE: February 10, 2008; 04:33 P.M.
COMMENT: Funny how the simplest things can be the most interesting. Great color contrast!

 

IMAGE: Architecture (Daytime) 1 of 2 No. 17/43 [black & white version]
FROM: Juan Carlos Bretschneider [photo.net member]
DATE:  January 30, 2008; 07:52 P.M.
COMMENT: Truly wonderful work Attila, not only has a superb composition, it also has terrific contrast and values; whether you shoot it in film or digital, it has the feeling of B&W film with a red and a polarizing filter, almost infra red. Congratulations!
 
IMAGE: Architecture (Daytime) 1 of 2 No. 17/43 [black & white version]
FROM: Laurent-Paul Robert [photo.net member]
DATE: February 01, 2008; 04:31 A.M.
COMMENT: Excellent composition. After looking at the color version, I personaly think I prefer this one which is even more dramatic.
 
IMAGE: Architecture (Daytime) 1 of 2 No. 17/43 [black & white version]
FROM: Paolo Casagranda [photo.net member]
DATE: February 01, 2008; 05:39 A.M.
COMMENT: Amazing perspective ...wonderful photo, from the contrast to the composition! P.
 
IMAGE: Architecture (Daytime) 1 of 2 No. 18/43 [colour version]
FROM: Juan Carlos Bretschneider [photo.net member]
DATE: January 30, 2008; 07:58 P.M.
COMMENT: So...it was done on the post processing; impressive job indeed. By the way, it looks great in color too. Cheers!
 
IMAGE: Architecture (Daytime) 1 of 2 No. 18/43 [colour version]
FROM: Younes Bounhar [photo.net member]
DATE: January 31, 2008; 01:04 P.M.
COMMENT: Love this!

 

IMAGE: Signage No. 17/25
FROM: Tero Pylkkänen [photo.net member]
DATE:  January 28, 2008; 10:04 A.M.
COMMENT: Attila - Kicking for the white spot :) Did you positioned it with purpose? I would personally like this more if it would have more space above the building.

 

IMAGE: Architecture (Daytime) 1 of 2 No. 8/43
FROM: Maria Di Liegro [photo.net member]
DATE: January 27, 2008; 10:31 P.M.
COMMENT: Hello Attila - The angle on this is great and I like the buildings themselves as well as the fog. - Maria